What Service Was Provided Only By Jewish Merchants? Why? Coursehero

Welcome to this week'south edition of "Transforming Teaching and Learning," a column that explores how colleges and professors are reimagining how they teach and how students learn. Please share your ideas hither for issues to examine, hard questions to ask and experiments -- successes and failures -- to highlight. If yous'd similar to receive the free "Transforming Instruction and Learning" newsletter, please sign upward hither. And please follow us on Twitter @ihelearning.

***

Gaye Theresa Johnson'due south initial feel with Class Hero almost a decade ago was non a positive 1. As an early-career faculty member at the University of California, Los Angeles, she discovered that some of her students were uploading her written report guides and tests to the sharing website, without permission, and that other students were using those materials.

"We were already in the digital age, just information technology however felt similar cheating to me," says Johnson. Every bit a then-junior professor in African American studies, Johnson hadn't copyrighted the material, and so she didn't share the concerns many instructors accept historically had nearly sites like Chegg, Quizlet and Grade Hero. But as someone who, now at 47 years of age, describes herself as "quondam school," "I still viewed it pretty antagonistically."

As time passed, though, Johnson's view shifted. Today'south students, she says, aren't like she was -- someone who got an opportunity to be educated in "the nearly traditional ways" (in-person, often in small classes), and had "great experiences … that were one of the major things that shaped me."

"Simply I am open enough to see that the students are not in that identify anymore -- that'due south non who they are. The world has changed," she says. "Just as I realized it wasn't realistic for me to say, 'No laptops in form anymore,' it'due south clear that students don't use the encyclopedia anymore. They use YouTube; they acquire through sharing."

She adds, "The tools accept changed; the scene has changed. If I don't cover this new mode that students are learning, I'grand doing them a disservice. We educators have to change, too."

Johnson says Course Hero has helped her embrace that change. She is non just ane of the xxx,000 faculty participants in Class Hero's instructor portal (the "kinesthesia society"), but she as well enthusiastically attends the company's annual educator conference and has had her teaching profiled on the visitor's website.

A decade agone, Inside Higher Ed and other publications were filled with headlines on faculty concerns most students' use of sites like Grade Hero for sharing grade materials. (One 2009 article in Within Higher Ed, entitled "Class Hero or Course Villain," featured numerous professors bemoaning the appearance of their copyrighted course materials on such quiz- and homework-sharing sites and others describing the portals as "really fertile ground for plagiarism and dishonesty.")

Simply that very same article also quoted a longtime adjunct instructor acknowledging the potential power of a learning-based social networking site. "Imagine business organization students at Stanford, Marist, University of Beijing and Academy of Paris connecting up exterior of their courses to written report together and peradventure even work on team projects," the instructor said dorsum and so. "This may become the 'study group' of the 21st century."

The copyright and cheating concerns take not disappeared, and less than a year ago faculty members at Purdue University objected to a partnership betwixt the institution'due south well-regarded Online Writing Lab and Chegg, citing cheating concerns.

Just the supportive views like those expressed by UCLA's Johnson seem to comfortably coexist aslope the lingering concerns. The shift has not been entirely coincidental, at least in Form Hero's instance. The company, says CEO and co-founder Andrew Grauer, has invested "meaningfully" in building kinesthesia support, funding fellowships with the Woodrow Wilson Foundation for Teaching and incentivizing kinesthesia members to participate in the content-sharing network aslope their students. (He declines to share a specific dollar corporeality.)

Course Hero made news in business and engineering publications last week by becoming the latest education applied science company to encounter its value soar past $1 billion. This column explores an issue birthday different from Form Hero's valuation: Has the company become a valued player in the learning ecosystem in the eyes of faculty members? Take concerns about copyright and cheating dissipated?

***

Form Hero was founded in 2006, one of a slew of websites that enabled students to post and download syllabi, worksheets, essays, previous exams and other class materials. Among its differentiators was that the materials were all tied to specific courses. Students pay either a monthly or an almanac fee to download material -- the fee tin be limited or waived if they themselves upload content to the marketplace. It is likewise ane of many places on the cyberspace where students can pay for tutoring help.

The company generated a good fleck of early criticism -- arguably a sign of its impact. Aggrieved faculty members complained that students were sharing instructors' intellectual property without their permission and enabling the sort of questionable sharing of academic work that previously was available just in a fraternity-house basement or a quiet meeting amidst the campus library stacks.

Course Hero officials at the time said that they responded aggressively to complaints brought under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, but that "as a user-generated content site, we don't review the content … Unfortunately, at times we recognize that users may submit materials that they don't accept rights to."

The company has likewise taken numerous steps to endeavour to gainsay adulterous (which we'll describe subsequently in the article).

None of those complaints seemed to impede Form Hero's growth amongst students. It now receives about 400 million visits a year; Grauer tells business publications that the company exceeds $100 million in revenue, mostly from well-nigh i million subscribers paying $40 a month or $120 a year. Most of the visits involve students exploring and using the site's roughly 30 one thousand thousand educational resources that their peers (and instructors) have shared. Visitors also can tap into Course Hero'southward tutoring network to get "24/7 homework help."

"Everything we do is designed to help students exercise, larn and become unstuck," says Grauer, who co-founded the company every bit a educatee at Cornell University.

A Focus on the Faculty

Edifice out the website's resource-sharing platform remains Course Hero'due south top priority. But its other 2 "large bets," Grauer says, are (ane) using the vast data at its disposal (in terms of the sorts of content and aid students are looking for) to create its own content and (2) building out its portal for educators.

"In that location are and so many great didactics faculty who are dedicated to active learning and to their pedagogy, and we're focused on bringing them into the ecosystem to make it richer and much more than powerful for our users," Grauer says.

While the site is even so geared primarily to students, Course Hero is amassing significant content nearly, for and from higher faculty members. Virtually 30,000 professors from colleges and universities in the U.S. have a presence on the platform -- many have profiles, while others take been subjects of highly produced videos of instructors Course Hero deems "master educators."

The company also two years agone started a fellowship program through the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Foundation, which in 2019 awarded grants of $xxx,000 to 4 tenure-track instructors and grants of $20,000 to iv adjuncts or instructors off the tenure rails.

"So many awards and fellowships don't actually recognize and applaud excellent postsecondary teaching," says Patrick Riccards, a spokesman for the Woodrow Wilson Foundation. "Nosotros believed nosotros could work with Course Hero to put forrard a good production, put together something that would positively affect the university."

Grauer said the focus on adjuncts was not accidental.

"About 70-75 percent of the [roughly] i.five million U.S. higher instructors are adjuncts often didactics courses at multiple institutions or working some other job trying to make ends meet," he says via email. "These educators have a need to find and create instruction and assessment materials ameliorate and faster. We think it is mission critical to support, amplify and celebrate these educators and their contributions. We are doing this by building a customs of practice that facilitates the sharing of those resources and their use -- for the benefit of students."

Course Hero's focus on making heroes out of the faculty is rather uncommon among technology companies, and its rationale for investing in professors sounds reasonable.

Just a skeptic (say, a reporter) might wonder if Class Hero is also making its big investment -- which clearly seems to be in the multiple millions of dollars a year -- to blunt the historical criticisms and win hearts and minds. "Does all this investment," I asked Grauer in an interview, "build kinesthesia back up for what you do?"

"I certainly hope and so," he replies. "But Grade Hero didn't -- doesn't -- demand to brand this investment in educators. Others haven't, or oasis't yet. But we recall the outcome of doing and then will be to brand a really powerful platform of chop-chop accessible and affordable resources from as many different people and places as possible. And we find that what educators seem to appreciate the most is simply having conversations with them and listening to them as they talk about their teaching. That'southward been at the eye of what we practice."

Course Hero officials certainly believe they've moved the needle on faculty stance. The company tracks educator stance through regular surveys, and its year-end poll of 800 educators found that 43 percent were aware of Form Hero, and of those, between iii-quarters and four-fifths were either positive or neutral in their views of the visitor, whether it helps students larn and whether they trusted it.

***

Faculty members like Gaye Johnson say Grade Hero meets their needs in multiple means. When she needed ideas for new classroom exercises or assessment problems, she "used to just enquire a friend or a colleague in my section," Johnson says. "But I like beingness part of a community where educators believe in that kind of sharing, and I desire to be able to do that across disciplines and across the country, not merely [with] the person across the hall."

She too believes that when a Course Hero-hired writer profiles i of her grade strategies, they will convey an understanding of her that few people beyond her classroom might meet.

"They asked me to explain why I teach this way, why I believe in democratization in education," Johnson says. "If someone were to follow me on Course Hero, they will encounter why I think what I do is important."

Barbara Oakley had slightly unlike reasons for embracing the Course Hero arroyo. Long earlier she was a professor of engineering at Oakland University and the creator of ane of the world'south nearly-attended massive open online courses (boasting 1.nine million enrollees), Oakley was an ground forces captain who had studied Russian but hated math.

When she returned to higher at historic period 26 to report technology, she felt similar an outsider. Oakley failed an early exam in a form on circuits, she says, because she didn't sympathise a concept the professor had never introduced in course. Other students didn't fail -- and when she pressed, she learned that well-nigh of them had had an old exam of his that revealed the play tricks.

"I never knew that was a thing to practise," Oakley says. "Yous had to get into a clique."

A platform similar Course Hero "helps level the playing field," Oakley says, letting students "who were similar me or had more disadvantages get some of that insider knowledge. Information technology gives students access to extra practice problems to work with.

"And it makes my life easier," she continues. "If you've been education a course for xv to 20 years, it's hard to come upwards with anything new, so you might outset to recycle erstwhile tests from five or ten years before. From my perspective, if a student wants to look at 5 to 10 years of my quondam tests and happens to detect something I'yard putting on [an test] again, that means they're working really hard, doing lots of problems."

And the Class Hero educational activity summit? "It's a really nice way of interacting with all of these wonderful, upbeat professors who are really open with their materials and want to assistance their colleagues become amend," Oakley says. "In that location'south nil amend for my teaching adrenaline than that."

***

David Rettinger appreciates that change is afoot in higher education, as professors like Gaye Johnson and Barbara Oakley suggest, and that kinesthesia members may non be adjusting sufficiently to it. It'southward a "totally legitimate signal that sharing documents tin can be beneficial in some particular cases and that tutoring can be legitimate in many cases," says Rettinger, professor of psychological sciences and managing director of academic programs at the Academy of Mary Washington, in Virginia.

College educational activity is evolving "to be more than collaborative and dynamic and less lecture/test/research paper-based," Rettinger adds. And when that happens, he says, "engineering and pedagogy will come together in ways that really benefit students."

Correct now, though, "there'due south a very serious gap between those things, and in my feel, faculty in the U.S. are largely naïve and unaware of the tremendous problem that technology is creating for contract cheating and file sharing."

Rettinger's other relevant role: president of the International Heart for Academic Integrity.

He goes out of his manner to say that he isn't anti-engineering science, and he says he believes "at that place'southward certainly a lot of legitimate learning that goes on on Course Hero" and other sites. (He acknowledges that his girl, an elementary school student, "uses Quizlet all the time" to notice extra problems to drill on.)

The philosophical premise backside sharing websites like Course Hero -- and behind getting a higher education, for that matter -- is that "there's some pedagogical learning value that comes out" of exploring the educational materials you lot might detect on such sites, Rettinger says.

Simply another major shift that's unfolding, he says, is that more and more students are inbound college -- and, one would presume, using platforms like Course Hero -- not to drive their learning but to pursue a credential. They may be less interested in learning, and more in getting the answers they need to cease a homework assignment.

While on the telephone with this reporter, Rettinger goes to Class Hero'southward 24-7 tutoring folio and identifies a set of pupil queries that seem designed to solicit answers to homework rather than to help a student build his or her agreement of the subject matter.

In his own field, cognitive psychology, he finds numerous study guides that students take created. "Could it be the example that someone'southward study guide could be helpful to their peers? Sure," he says. "But I always tell my students to make their own report guide -- that'south the best way to larn the material. Then here is a shortcut that is actively unhelpful to their peers."

Information technology gets worse, Rettinger continues. "I encounter a lot of papers on there -- completed work in response to prompts. That to me is a recipe to encouraging people to cheat.

"It's a marketplace. If Napster was shut down for existence a piracy site, I don't see how this is dissimilar.... They may say, 'Information technology'due south not our mistake if students utilise our tool for ill -- nosotros ask them not to.' But I recollect we can generally concord that when yous lower the bar for doing something dishonest, you're contributing to that dishonest behavior."

"Even if you tell me only a third is file [of the activity on Course Hero] is sharing for cheating purposes, they've got millions of users."

Rettinger ultimately believes that transparency is at the cadre of this problem. "If students knew where faculty were getting the resource nosotros were using, and students were transparent about where they were getting their answers, this wouldn't really be an effect," he says.

"If yous're my student and you want to utilize Course Hero tutoring, take at it," he says. "Transport me the transcript and so I can run into what you were struggling with and how they helped. If you're unwilling to share that, I'd have to ask, 'What are you hiding?'"

***

Grauer, the Course Hero CEO and co-founder, says the company combats potential academic misconduct in every way information technology can. Any time it identifies cases of abuse, "or where it becomes exceedingly clear that at that place is corruption," site monitors "remove that content."

"And if we first to identify different keyword phrases that seem to violate standards of academic integrity, we don't let those questions" to become through to tutors.

Beyond individual reports or cases, Course Hero "makes the content in our library as indexable past search engines as possible," Grauer says. "If they're going to use content from our site and plow it in equally their own, we've made information technology equally like shooting fish in a barrel equally possible for that to be detected" past instructors.

"Through moderation, nosotros commit to doing our best to protect and uphold academic integrity," he says. "That said, in an open platform like this, the issues you lot talked about are going to come upwards, and we demand to respond to them promptly and thoughtfully."